Home / Human Rights Oversight / Subnational Oversight
Northeastern University School of Law
Center for Global Law and Justice
Subnational Oversight
Local Human Rights Commissions
In many countries, subnational human rights commissions operate at the municipal, county, state, or provincial levels, overseeing implementation of human right norms in their localities. In some instances, these bodies are charged with investigating and adjudicating complaints arising under national and local civil rights laws. Subnational human rights commissions are also often active in promoting human rights education in communities and hosting dialogues to address human rights concerns. Often, these subnational bodies coordinate activities, share information, and work collectively to promote human rights on a national scale.
Find your local Human Rights Commission by accessing the IAOHRA Membership Directory of the International Association of Official Human Rights Agencies (IAOHRA).
Sample Local Human Rights Commissions
- Unlocking the Power and Possibility of Local Enforcement of Human and Civil Rights: Lessons Learned from the NYC Commission on Human Rights
- State and Local Human Rights Agencies: Recommendations for Advancing Opportunity and Equality Through an International Human Rights Framework
- Human Rights Institutionalization at the Local Level: A Case Study of Sub-National Human Rights Commissions in Korea
- HRCs as an Effective Tool for Municipalities. https://www.dcba.org/mpage/v33-Christopher-Holland
- State and Local Commissions as Sites for Domestic Human Rights Implementation (Ch. 5)
Establishing a Local HRC
- Cities, Local and Regional Governments and Human Rights
- Achievements and Challenges of Human Rights Commissions in US Cities
- Making Human Rights Real: A Workbook on the Local Implementation of Human Rights
Sample Ordinances and By-Laws
Sample HRC submissions to UN bodies
Voluntary Local Reviews
The Sustainable Development Goals, also known as Agenda 2030, were adopted by all United Nations members in 2015. The 17 goals aim to achieve “peace and prosperity” for the planet by, among other things, addressing climate change, promoting equality, and ending poverty. As part of the SDG implementation process, the UN developed a process for nations governments to report their progress through Voluntary National Reviews (VNRs). This initial process did not include an independent role for local governments, but by 2018, several local governments began preparing their own progress reports, called Voluntary Local Reviews (VLRs). New York City submitted the first VLR to the UN in 2018. Since that time, hundreds of local and regional governments around the world have prepared and submitted VLRs, with many providing updates after their initial filings. In response, the UN has begun to recognize this movement and develop processes to support local and regional governments in monitoring and implementing the SDGs.
- Global Guiding Elements for VLRs (UNDESA)
- What’s in a Voluntary Local Review? SDG Progress in the Nordics (Nordregio)
- A VLR Handbook for Cities (Carnegie Mellon University, Heinz College)
- A Resource for Localities with Limited Resources (Institute for Global Environmental Strategies)
- Guidelines for Voluntary Subnational Reviews (United Cities and Local Governments) (Alternate link)
- Asia-Pacific Regional Guidelines on VLRs (Economic and Social Commission for the Pacific)
- VLR: A Handbook for UK Cities (Cabot Institute for the Environment, University of Bristol)
- Enhanced VLR Guidance Portal
UNDESA’s Enhanced VLR Guidance Portal provides information for officials, experts, and organizations to create a VLR. - SDG Actions Platform
The SDG Actions Platform is a global registry of voluntary policies, commitments, multi-stakeholder partnerships and other initiatives made by governments, the UN system and a broad range of stakeholders to support the SDGs. - We Act. Resilient Cities and Regions (UCLG).
- Making Cities Resilient 2030 – A Global Community to Drive Local and Territorial Resilience.
Human Rights Cities
The Human Rights Cities movement was launched by the People’s Movement for Human Rights Learning following the 1993 World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna, Austria. These is no single indicator of human rights city status, but in 2011, the 1st World Human Rights Cities Forum of Gwangju, South Korea, defined Human Rights Cities as “both a local community and a socio-political process in a local context where human rights play a key role as fundamental values and guiding principles.” Generally, human rights cities have taken some formal steps to incorporate human rights norms into city laws, policies, and practices. Human Rights Cities exist throughout the world, including in Europe, Asia, North and South America, and Africa.
- What are human rights cities?
- Global Urban Justice: The Rise of Human Rights Cities. The first book-length scholarly treatment of the human rights cities movement
- The Human Rights City: New York, San Francisco, Barcelona
- “A Glass Half Full: Can Local Human Rights Commissions Save International Law in the United States,” UC Irvine Journal of International, Transnational, and Comparative Law (forthcoming)
- Research Handbook on International Law and Cities, “Finding International Law ‘Close to Home’: The Case of Human Rights Cities”
- Human Rights Cities Indicators (RWI)
- What is a HRC? (RWI)
- Human Rights Cities and the SDGs
- Integrated Implementation of Scotland’s New Human Rights Framework: Workshop Series Findings
- Human Rights Cities and Regions: Swedish and International Perspectives
- Human Rights Go Local Publication Series
- Localizing Human Rights in Cities (Tamar Ezer)
- (G)local Intersectionality (Martha Davis)
- Mapping Perceptions of Human Rights and Cultivating Boston as a Human Rights City
Information for Human Rights Cities
- Global Charter: Agenda for Human Rights in the City
- Guiding Principles on Human Rights Cities from the Human Rights Cities Forum
- Human Rights Cities in the EU: Practical Guidance
- RWI Free Course: Human Rights Budgeting & Corruption in Local Level Governance
- Global Charter-Agenda for Human Rights in the City
- City of Miami: Title VI/Nondiscrimination Program Plan
Establishing A Human Rights City
- A resource document for Human Rights Cities
- Recommendations for Human Rights City Organizing Building on Past Lessons and Practices
- Human Rights Impact Assessment Guidance and Toolbox
- Standardized Monitoring System (EU HRC Pilot)
- Webinar: Imagining Winnipeg as a HRC
- Human Rights Cities in the EU: A Framework for Reinforcing Rights Locally
- Global Cities Hub Connecting local and regional governments to the United Nations and other international organizations
- Tips for Local and Regional Governments in the UPR. Tips for Local and Regional Governments that wish to participate in the Universal Periodic Review (UPR). The UPR is a process in which the Human Rights Council of the UN reviews the human rights records of all UN Member States
Campaigns
Cities for CEDAW
Cities for CEDAW is a United States-based grassroots movement to encourage subnational governments to endorse and implement the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). The United States is one of only six UN member nations that have not ratified CEDAW. Cities for CEDAW aims to encourage local governments to honor the women’s rights treaty while also increasing pressure on the US national government to ratify the Convention.
- Cities for CEDAW org is working on publishing a model ordinance
- Implementing CEDAW as a Local Ordinance
- 2017 Gender Equity Resolution Adopted by the International Association of Official Human Rights Agencies (IAOHRA)
- To see a list of sample CEDAW resolutions, etc., visit Cities for CEDAW – Resources and scroll to Sample Resolutions, Ordinances and Executive Directives.
- Cities for CEDAW, as explained by Soon-Young Yoon, the former UN Rep for International Alliance of Women
- Cities for CEDAW: Notes on the Road to Effective Intervention
- About the Cities for CEDAW Campaign
- Washington, D.C., Just O.K.’d a Law Equalizing Women’s Rights. Why Can’t the US Senate Do the Same?
- UNDP Human Development Report: The Paths to Equal: Twin Indices on Women’s Empowerment and Gender Equality
- Looking for Change in Gender Equality? Look Locally
- Cities for CEDAW Toolkit (UNA USA)
- Cities for CEDAW Fact Sheet
- IAOHRA: Gender Equity Toolkit
- Tips on Talking to an Official about Cities for CEDAW
- Building a City Action Coalition for a CEDAW City: “The Nuts and Bolts”
- Cities for CEDAW: A Campaign to Make the Global Local
- Local Implementation of CEDAW: Advancing the Rights of Women and Girls in LAC
- A Guide to Effective Meetings with Local Elected Officials
- Understanding CEDAW Cities: A Descriptive Analysis
- Prospects for Realizing International Women’s Rights Law Through Local Governance: The Case for Cities for CEDAW
- Cities for CEDAW Recommendations (ZONTA International – USA Caucus)
- Training: Sustaining Mother Earth (Soon-Young Yoon)
Stay Informed
Stay informed by subscribing to one or both of our mailing lists:
CGLJ News and CGLJ Resource Hub Newsroom!